[Tribeca Review] Democrats
Knowing that dictator Robert Mugabe is still the leader of Zimbabwe doesn't detract from the drama of Camilla Nielsson's documentary Democrats. The film covers the drafting of the country's new constitution, and while recent history is technically a spoiler, the intrigue comes from watching the struggle of ideologies embodied by two opposing individuals. Our primary subjects are Paul Mangwana, who represents Mugabe's ruling ZANU-PF party, and Douglas Mwonzora, who represents the reform-minded opposition MDC-T.
Democrats is about the political process and its headaches, and about a struggle taking place over the course of three years. Nielsson has remarkable access to her two primary subjects and captures many of the impasses and compromises over this stretch of time. She also chronicles various calculated (and corrupt) maneuvers made by ZANU-PF to suppress the opposition. Mangwana smiles as he discusses some of these power plays on camera. He senses, he knows, that the power of the people is often nothing when compared to the power of the state.
Democrats
Director: Camilla Nielsson
Rating: N/A
Release Date: TBD
Early in the film, we see the influence of Mugabe's cult of personality as well as his strong-arm tactics. The arms of the Mugabe government beat voters, they suppress voices, they intimidate opposition. Open constitutional meetings are held with average citizens voicing their political wishes. Those loyal to ZANU-PF pledge fealty to Mugabe and the status quo. Opposing voices feel pressured to remain quiet under threat of violence and imprisonment. ZANU-PF uses other methods of misdirection to squelch dissenting voices, and they don't try that hard to conceal them.
All the while, Mangwana laughs.
His party controls many of the instruments of accountability. No one else can hold them accountable without being threatened. This includes members of the press. Given all this, Mangwana's confident transparency is both refreshing as well as disheartening.
As the face of the political opposition, Mwonzora is high-minded and carries himself with grace and patience. All of these qualities are necessary given the power imbalance MDC-T faces. Like the best political idealists, he's driven by optimism and the belief that concerned people can make a difference. It just takes a lot of effort and time, and that's the problem. Who has the privilege of either given the state of the country? An underlying tension throughout Democrats is how much frustration and setback Mwonzora can take. It's hard not to see the cracks in the brave facade, and it's harder still to not admire this sort of resolve.
Even though stretches of Democrats are built around meetings and party discussions, Nielsson does an admirable job of making the various political maneuvers understandable and engaging. This is thanks in large part to the personalities of Mwonzora and Mangwana, who make excellent foils for one another. We're watching a series of moves made for the political long-game and short-game in Zimbabwe, and it'll be interesting to see what change, if any, eventually comes about.
At one point of Democrats, Mangwana laughs and smiles at the camera as he talks-up the power of the Mugabe government. They have the police, they have the courts, they have so many systems in place against dissenters. Mangwana asks what power words and a legal understanding can make given this disparity. We learn in Democrats what difference they make to the process, but outside the film, we'll have to wait for a definitive answer.