The mess that is Batman vs. Superman just became a bit cleaner today. Variety is reporting that Warner Bros. really want Joaquin Phoenix (Her) to portray an antagonist in the upcoming sequel to Man of Steel. While sources haven’t confirmed the role, it’s assumed to be for the film’s main villain and Superman’s greatest adversary, Lex Luthor. However, an official offer hasn’t been made, and there’s no indication that Phoenix would even want to take on the role.

As can be seen by his resume since 2010’s controversial I’m Still Here, the actor has been more interested in visceral, smaller budget films in lieu of big Hollywood productions. The opportunity to join such a huge property, especially one that features a cast that includes Ben Affleck and the recently-announced Gal Gadot, is a tough one to balk at. Still, I’m holding on to the chance that Breaking Bad‘s Bryan Cranston will ultimately be cast for the film.

Nevertheless, we’ll report more as the story develops.

[via Variety]